Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Should any book be banned?

 We were asked to write about if we think a book should be banned under any circumstance. I say NO!! Several reasons come to mind as why they shouldn't be banned. First, of course, is Freedom of Speech. We have built this country on a foundation that allows us to say whatever we want, good or bad. We have fought many battles over the first amendment to protect our RIGHT! Banning a particular book would be going against what we have fought so hard for, whether we like the book or not. Besides, we can not escape the hardships and cruelty of the world by banning a single book in a classroom. 

The American Library Association describes why books are banned, in order "to protect others, frequently children, from difficult ideas and information." Banning a book because it has a swear word doesn't stop their children from learning it from television, movies, music, or even down the street by someone who just stubbed their toe! Racism is something we have to acknowledge in order to prevent it. A book that depicts racism doesn't stop a child from, again, learning it from somewhere else. I would much rather a child learn about racism from a book in a controlled environment, and see how it's wrong with a teacher or parent explaining why, then out on the streets and seeing that sometimes it's OK. Today's media isn't concerned with censorship or setting a good example for young children. It is ultimately up to the parent to teach their child right from wrong. They need to take an active roll in their children's lives and explain to them how the world works and to take things "with a grain of salt." As much as they fight it, they cannot protect their children from everyday issues. 

No matter what you may do, this world is going to be filled with crude language, racism, pornography, and inappropriate behavior. Banning a book will not stop the rest of the world from contaminating a child. It is better to read about it in a book and see the error in their ways. The best defense is knowledge, this is why we need literate children.

1 Comments:

At June 29, 2008 at 3:27 PM , Blogger Lilly Buchwitz said...

Your argument seems to suggest that it's OK for children to read pornography. Do you think so?

Yes, this country has a law about freedom of speech, but remember that doesn't give people the right to yell fire in a crowded theater. There are subtleties, and the fact that books *are* banned, even today, means you need to think deeper about why, and whether that's right or wrong.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home